Used Cover Girl Clump Crusher for years, but it seems to have been discontinued. I tried this as a replacement and glad I did. It's a decent price/value. It stays on - no clumping, smudging, no racoon eyes. It's easy to remove. It doesn't make my eyelashes look like women in mascara commercials on TV, but it does the job at a fair price with no negatives I can think of. This will be my new go-to mascara.
I have used this product for years and it's only improved in quality. It has become a little pricey so I wait for the package of 2 to stock up. I like that it comes in blk/dn which is hard to find. I'll still be using it in the next 10 yrs unless they discontinue it.
This is the only mascara I have found that doesn't clump, doesn't run, and is available in waterproof brown. I use it every day.
Bought for my elderly mom who uses it for eyelashes and eyebrow. She loves it.
I've tried so many other mascaras some much more expensive, but I always come back to this one. It goes on smoothly and does not clump even at second coat. Stays on all day and doesn't flake and it washes of well unlike some other non water proof mascaras that just clump up when you try remove it.I've been using this brand for many years and it never disappoints.