I have used this mascara for several years. When they say waterproof, they aren't kidding. It takes quite a bit of makeup remover to get it off. No smudges though. Never get raccoon eyes even on the hottest daysI have had it clump a bit, but nothing troublesome. If you need mascara that stays put, this is for you.
This mascara is a good solid eye product. Dies not clump and adds length to your lashes. Very easy to remove when removing makeup.