I am old school and don’t like liquid eye liners. I love this pencil eyeliner. I have used it many times and have not sharpened it yet.
I wear this daily on my lower lid waterline. It reduces the appearance of tiredness and makes my eyes look bright
This is a long lasting pencil that doesn’t smudge. It’s a pencil that has to be sharpened about every 4th or 5th time you use it. It’s comparable to the much more expensive Estée Lauder eyeliner pencil.
I like this liner but does fade over the day. Sometimes it smudges if I put too much on the bottom lid. But I’ve managed to make it work for me.