This is my favorite eyeliner, and has been for many years. It’s long lasting and easy to apply. The Saturn grey color is nearly impossible to find, but Amazon has it!
My very favorite eye liner! Soft crayon that goes on smoothly and no sparkles. The Saturn grey has always been my go to color. It's dark enough to be in the black family and not so light it's invisible. In fact I go over the application with a powdered shadow to lock it in place and it stays all day.
I've been using Avon Glimmersticks for decades. The Saturn Grey is preferable because the highlight is softer than black or starry blue.