Clean and safe during pregnancy. It was easy to apply. Bold and black and long lasting.The first time I applied it I forgot for a second I had on eyeliner and rubbed one eye for a couple of seconds and my eyeliner was still on and not smudged!!
I have been trying to move towards less toxic makeup and this one was rated relatively good.I tried it and thought it stood up pretty well.When I put it on at 7-8am it preformed until about 3pm.Then, I needed to reapply.Other, less toxic eye liners can get all over the place.So, within that sub-category of products, I think it is good.I will keep using it.
I LOVE this liner.It does have a thicker tip but the tip is highly flexible.So you can apply it thin, or angle your hand and make a thicker line, if that makes sense.I've tried the cat eye thing and messed up---it easily wiped away when you act quickly.I would NOT call this smudge proof--it definitely smudges...Nothing too bad but if you rub your eyes (allergies) it will smudge.I only use this as a top liner.I would buy again.I mainly bought due to its clean ingredients.
This liquid liner is fantastic! It goes on easily (as long as your hand is steady), immediately dries & STAYS PUT. It doesn’t transfer to my lids like other liquid liners I’ve tried. I love it!