JOAH Make Her Gel-ous Gel Eyeliner with Self-Sharpening Pencil, Waterproof & Long-Lasting Color Definition, Black - REVIEW

  • I like this eyeliner because it goes on smooth, it has a mechanical advance so you don't have to sharpen, and it is fairly waterproof although it will smudge sometimes.My main complaint is I ordered the 1 oz. size and what I received is the .017 oz. size.That is quite a difference in the amount of product.Has anyone actually received this product with 1 oz?
  • I love love love this eyeliner!!! This is a great liner!! It is easy to apply. I also ordered this product for my daughter & she absolutely loves it too. I will continue to purchase this brand
  • I feel that it was a great value for what I paid for it and it was very easy to use
  • This glides on nicely and has very nice/rich color.I had purchased based on a magazine review for its use on the waterline.Unfortunately, it did not last all day as I had hoped. But I will continue to use as regular liner.
  • This pencil is easy to use, makes a clean line and looks great. It lasts for a long time and is easy to be smoothed for a softer line.
  • I like to smudge my eyeliner, then return with a soft black line near my eyelash- and this product is perfect for this application. Love it - and receive it regularly with a subscription!
View on Amazon


  • Gel Eyeliner: Our no-tug waterproof eyeliner formula delivers intense color that glides on as effortlessly as a liquid liner with the control of a pencil. The creamy gel texture never skips over fine lines or wrinkles and delivers a long-lasting finish.
View on Amazon