Silly George Heart Eyes Mascara | Smudge-Free, Budge-Free, Grudge-Free Lashes, Cruelty Free & Vegan - REVIEW

  • I have just started using this mascara and so far so good. It. is true what they say this mascara is really smudge proof!! I mostly use on my lash extensions but it works great on my natural lashes as well. My lasheslooked so thick and full after. And the packaging is the cutest!! Best mascara I have used in a while.
  • Amazing mascara! It works beautifully and I've used it with the Silly George falsies. I apply this to my real lashes then add the Silly George falsies and I'm good to go all day. No flaking. No clumping.
  • It’s one of the very best mascaras that I’ve try it! So the same day I received it I got a Gucci mascara from Sephora so I tried them both same time different eyes and WOW this one way better than Gucci and any other one I have. I can say it’s very similar to one of my MAC but can’t remember the name however this one is better because it’s not like a glue!! You can remove it easily without smashing your eyes 😅 I remove it with Clinique take the day off then a bit of micellar water just to make sure everything is clean before I use my white towel. It gives great volume. However, it’s not an extension so don’t expect it to be that great if you initially have short think lashes. It’s so great for someone with medium/long straight lashes so it will make it look more curly and longer.
  • It is hard to find a mascara that can deliver length and volume, but this one does! It is a "tubing" mascara, so when you go to remove it at the end of the day, do not be alarmed that you are losing all of your lashes. The tubes slide off easily without any pulling or tugging. It is so cool to experience. I have not had any flaking or smudging either. This is a great formula, and I will definitely repurchase!
  • I've tried several new mascaras recently, and this one is my favorite, hands-down.The double applicator is really cool. You untwist the top to get a thin layer that provides length, or untwist the lower section to get a thick layer that provides volume. The wand has good control and coats the lashes smoothly.Unlike many mascaras, this one doesn't seem to clump at all. It adds a natural-looking coating to the lashes and made mine look about 30% longer without appearing goopy or fake. This is probably the most natural-looking product I've tried, to be honest.I would say this is "smudge resistant," but NOT smudge-proof. If you rub your eyes hard enough, it will smudge. It's semi-water-proof. It removes easily with oil, so if you have any oil on your skin or hands, this will make it slide.There's argan oil in the ingredients. There's no particular odor, it doesn't reek of chemicals or perfumes. The current price of $17 seems fair. Great product.
  • I’ve never heard of this brand before but I’m starting to look at all their products in this line. It’s a bit pricer than the drug store brands but it’s cheaper than the luxury brands and work just as great. Easy to wipe off
  • I like the volume and length that I can achieve with the Silly George Heart Eyes Mascara.I can quickly create a "false lashes" look and build the length and volume that I prefer.This is a dual wand mascara and I use the first wand to coat my lashes and the second to refine and add length.I prefer mascara that has one easy-to-use wand.The mascara has been harder than ideal to remove.I have to use one particular cleanser that removes makeup with minimal effort.It truly has been smudge-free and budge-free as described but removal is not as easy as described.If you are looking for a lash building mascara that stays in place, this is a good choice.
  • It’s nice that you can choose if you want a lot of mascara or just a little. It has two options for you to choose from. I didn’t know that it had fibers in it though. On the smaller one the inside came out but went right back in. I woke up not having raccoon eyes which is a plus. I always forget to wash off the makeup before bed. It does make your lashes look good too.
  • This mascara has a really nice design. It is very easy to use with smooth application. I love the dual wands. The volume wand is great for dramatic lashes - it increases both volume and length. The lengthening wand is better for an every day, casual look. It dries quickly, stays well, and is easily removable. Great mascara!
  • Current price $17.00.Very unique mascara. You can pull the brush out two different ways - if you twist only the top, the mascara is applied to the brush for length, and if you twist the center off, the mascara is applied to the brush for volume. It's the same brush but the opening in the bottom increases so you get more mascara on the brush, so the mascara goes on thicker. Love the mascara. It doesn't smudge, or clump and looks great! 4 Stars. Hope you find this review and pictures helpful. Separates lashes nicely - reasonably priced!
  • Good mascara. I don’t find the two-piece wand system to be all that useful for me personally, as I don’t find it’s necessary and kind of gimmicky (you have the option to pull the wand through the top of the first section and sort of further wipe-off the wand before applying it). I suppose it’s useful if you like a lighter application. I also found the formula a little more fiber-filled and fuzzy compared to some of my other volumizing favorites. With that said, this did build my lashes quickly and easily. It didn’t flake at all and it looked really pretty. I liked it overall. More of a 3.5 stars, but I’ll go with four stars here. Made in China/PRC
  • I wasn't to hopeful when I ordered this mascara.I usually don't stray from my standby brands.However, this was a win for me.I have sensitive eyes and this doesn't bother me at all.I thought I would prefer the lengthening option, but I actually like the thickening one.It lasts through the whole day and comes off easily with a baby wipe at the end of the day.I would use this mascara again.
  • The media could not be loaded. When I first applied this mascara I thought it was just a regular mascara. I didn’t know it was a tubing mascara. After doing a little research on what a tubing mascara is, I actually like it! It’s perfect for a very natural lash extension, kind of look! Great for those that want to enhance their natural lash without looking clumpy!
  • I really like the way it made my eyes pop! It doesn’t feel heavy, and my eyes look very pretty! I have a winner!
  • This Silly George Heart Eyes Mascara was available to me through the Amazon Vine program.The mascara is unique in that it has 2 positions in which to open it.If you open it at the first (bright pink) cap, you get a lengthening wand.If you open it at the second (light pink) cap, you get a volumizing wand.I was curious if this was just a gimmick, but the wands ARE different with the volumizing wand applying more mascara.The mascara is smudge proof, vegan, and free from parabens and sulfates.It is an interesting concept, but it does cost over twice as much as my go-to mascara.(Yes, it is like 2 different mascaras, but there is not twice the amount.)This mascara is made in China (PRC).
  • Love that I wore this all day and don’t have raccoon eyes! I don’t have any smudges or flakes. I think the dual brush idea is really great too.Sometimes I need length and sometimes I want volume.I felt like both brushes did what they said they would do. It’s a really interesting concept and it’s cool to have both options in one bottle.Definitely recommend!
  • Works really good! This brand offers a lot of good quality and fun inventive products!! Makes my eyelashes thick and long! Very giftable!
  • This is a black mascara with the option for less or more on the wand via 2 different caps. It is very smooth and not clumpy. It makes my spare lashes look visible (they are white) and the thickening allows me to get them to curl. Black is a but dramatic for me, I’d buy this in brown.I struggle with eye makeup reactions but this is easy to tolerate. Works well for me.
  • This mascara works great! I apply it give me more length and thickness without the clumps. It's easy to apply thanks to the wand and wears well. I have no smudging and it lasts all day.
  • I love that this is more natural than a lot of the store bought brands.Great volume and goes on easily
  • I love this mascara! I won’t have to look any further. It lengthens and curls, doesn’t smudge or clump, and washes off easily, no need for eye makeup remover.
  • Mascara is one of those beauty products I'm alwayson the hunt for. I've never found one that doesn't flake, smudge or clump. This was one was love at first swipe! It's never clumpy or flakey and it doesn't make me look like a raccoon at the end of the day. I'm very satified with my purchase and will definitely be repurchasing!
  • This is my favorite mascara. The top gives a lot of length. I can make the angled cat eyes easily. When I want volume for a less obvious look, the bottom one works great. It doesn't smudge, even when I rub my eyes. This is a tremendous value, especially because you get two in one.Thank you for reading, I hope you found this helpful.
  • SilLy George Heart Eyes Mascara has two application settings that give lashes length and volume. It is smudge proof and long lasting. This product is easy to apply and great for everyday use. It is cruelty free, vegan, sulfate free and paraben free.I highly recommend this product!
  • I loved this mascara.My lashes looked longer and had volume.It is budge-proof and smudge-proof, and everyone needs that kind of staying power.What I was excited about was the dual wands,one for volume and one for length.Due to my budget I don't spend over $10 for mascara, this item is priced at $20, but worth it.Very happy.
  • The dual wand mascara is a unique system that includes two wands in the same product. One wand is designed for length and the other for volume. The mascara goes on smoothly but it takes several coats to build the volume that I get with other mascaras. It doesn’t flake or smudge and is actually a bit difficult to remove. The mascara is OK but for the price I expected better.
  • This works really well for me. Before discovering this mascare, by the end of the daymore of my mascara was usually under my eyes than on them, so this really helped me.It gives great volume to my lashes and easily removes at the end of the day with makeup remover or face wash.I like that I don't have to check my makeup mid afternoon worrying if I need to do a touch up/clean up.
  • This mascara is INCREDIBLE! I am a mascara junkie and normally shell out $$ for the high end brands. This is now my favorite! It applies the perfect amount and doesn’t clump. It also does not budge all day long. No flaking! I love the option for the thicker brush or tiny brush for lower lashes and lash tips. Removes easily with face wash.
  • This is a pretty nice mascara but I do notice that it flakes off at the end of the day if it's been a long day (like up at 8am to go to the office and then meeting with friends and out until 7pm). I bought a sampler pack of mini mascaras a few months ago and nothing has beat Clinique's high impact mascara for me.I keep Silly George in my rotation -- it gives good volume and fullness. Only downside is it flakes for me on the long days.
  • I love that this mascara gives you two different volume options. It’s the same brush but you can pull it through a smaller hole or a larger hole depending on how much mascara you want to apply. I’m personally a less is more kind of girl so I pull the brush out through the small hole to add more length and less volume. I also like the brush shape. I would say it’s a classic cylinder with a taper shape- my preferred shape. It glides on easily and smoothly with minimal maneuvering. It dries quickly and I haven’t had any issues with smudging.
  • I was intrigued by this dual purpose mascara. I usually have 3 mascaras in my arsenal (length, volume, and waterproof). If I am feeling really fancy, and have the time, sometimes I use the latter 2 to get the desired effect of thick and long lashes. I do have oily skin and basically no time in the morning so 2-in-1 anything is helpful. The product description did not detail how this mascara worked so I included the photos. The same mascara juice and brush is used for either effect. The difference is it you choose the lengthening option (the top lid) the brush is squeezed through the tube of the inner lid and which greatly reduces the amount of mascara juice on the brush to allow more definition to lashes. I love this engineering! Now I can go for the fuller, thicker look but when I need to fix a small section or just separate clumps I just squeeze off the excess and get to work. I occasionally want a lighter makeup look and use the lengthening outer tube to give just a couple of swipes and my lashes look long and quite natural. Honestly, this is smart engineering for a tube of mascara and I will no longer need to keep a clean eyelash brush for emergency de-clumpling in my makeup bag. So really, Silly George could replace 3 items in the arsenal which just made it my go to travel mascara. Furthermore, their claim of smudge-free wear is absolutely true for my oily eyelids! The mascara itself is nice and thick too, not too runny and smeary to begin with but even better after it dries.I really love this mascara. I usually stick with the inner tube for a fuller effect, which also still lengthens a little. I follow up with the outer lid to tidy up if I get too much product or I want to add a little length to my full lashes. I do worry the tube will go quickly because the extra inner tube is taking up real estate inside the holding tube but I’m willing to chance it. I am typically satisfied with drug store brands of mascara and only splurge occasionally but I can honestly tell you that I plan to keep Silly George Heart Eyes in my daily routine during the summer months. It is great for travel and I expect the smudge-free formula to do well with summertime sweat and humidity. And right now as I type this, my lashes look better with Silly George than my old tried and true brands. Seriously!!! I would definitely recommend to a friend or stranger!
  • Absolutely love this mascara. I have oily skin and this mascara does not smudge at all. I love that there’s two options of wand types. I’ve been using this mascara for awhile now. Lasts a long time.
View on Amazon

Description

  • LENGTHEN AND VOLUMIZE: With two application settings of this tubing mascara, you can plump up the volume and/ or add lashings of length, all in the one terribly cute tube
  • BREAKTHROUGH TECHNOLOGY: The SG signature formula uses technology that creates a tube around the lash thickening and lengthening in one slick movement, which doesn’t smudge, and certainly won’t budge
  • SMUDGE-FREE AND LONG-LASTING: Perfect for oily eyelids or watery eyes, this unique formula will give you only tears of delight, lasting all day (and night) without smudging
  • HOW TO USE: Easy to apply. We recommend curling your lashes and applying the tubing Mascara for a stand out lash lift, on its own or before adding your (optional) Girl Series or SuperNatural Lashes
  • GENTLE FORMULATION: Cruelty Free & Vegan, Sulphate Free, Paraben Free
View on Amazon