I recently went to a local MAC counter and they were sold out of this eyeliner. I am so glad I was able to find it online through this provider. It is my favorite brand.
I’ve been using this eyeliner for many years now.It has changed, I think it used to boast being waterproof but it really is not.Nice deep black color that applies smoothly for a pencil type and the retractable feature is a plus.Does not have a smudging sponge on other end and no sharpener either.Works best if you use a setting spray when done but even then you still end up with some smudges under the wing.I just keep an eye on it and wipe a little as my day goes on.There’s probably better and less expensive retractable eyeliner out there but I haven’t really tried to find it yet.
Have used this product for years. Love it. fragrance free. stays in place. lasts all day. will keep buying it. love it
MAC is the only gel eyeliner I use because I much prefer it to other brands I've tried. I didn't give 5 stars because I don't buy it for water resistance, so can't comment, and I do find it smudges a bit unless I put a primer on. I do think it's a bit pricey, but worth it. It does glide on easily. Definitely recommended.