Make Up For Ever Smoky Extravagant Mascara, Black, 0.23 Ounce - REVIEW

  • Being a natural red head my eye-brows and lashes are almost translucent.Without mascara and brow products I don't have a face.Most mascaras have too much product on the wand and my eyes look like I stuck a fuzzy blackcaterpillar to my eye.This mascara gives great coverage with ONE application and you can see my lashes.It's worth the money.
  • I LOVE this product & have been using it for years! No clumps & easily comes off!
  • Makes you look like you have false lashes it works so well! Only stuff I use.
  • This is the only mascara I ever use.Love it!I usually order the waterproof but this works just as well and I never see the dreaded smudge under my eyes.
  • I had a trial sample of this productAnd love the angle of the brush !!!!
  • I like how the wand applies the product.It separates and lengthens the lash and its not too cakey.But It's not exactly waterproof.It's water resistant, but it smudges when I blink and sweat and leaves a ring under my eye that's hard to remove.I can't just lick my finger to remove it and I can't remove it with makeup remover or else it takes off my face makeup.Next time, I'll just get the regular. Not waterproof.Otherwise, I really like it.
  • This is my go-to mascara.I love the way it goes on and really elongates, thickens, and separates my lashes.
  • Non-clumpy and goes on great. I really loved this formula, I always get a lot of compliments when I wear this mascara.
  • Received a sample from Sephora and have been in love ever since. Creates beautiful long lashes.
  • I am in my 60’s and have been searching for a mascara that lengthens my lashes without clumping and without the added fibers that flake into my eyes.This mascara is the best!It builds length and looks so natural without clumping.I would have preferred a water resistant formula because of allergies that cause my eyes to water.But I am so pleased with this formula, I’ll keep using it and purchase more when it runs out.
  • This Mascara stays on looks great with no clumping and comes offvery easily .It is very water proof and does not end up on my aging eye lids :)
  • Best mascara ever! Goes on evenly and stays on your lashes rather than creating raccoon eyes. The applicator brush is perfect - expensive but worth the investment. Tried "better than sex" mascara and it was junk - "make up for ever" is the way to go!
  • I love this mascara. My daughter gave me my first tube and it's the only mascara I have used since. Gives volumn without the clumping and the brush is the best!
  • i'm kind of a mascara junkie but often I'm left disappointed, not so with this one. I had a sample and was so impressed i bought the full size. It makes your lashes HUGE and stays on all day. It's a keep. worth the price.
  • LOVE THIS! I swear my almost non-existent lashes have grown longer since using this product. Not sure why, but I like it!
  • Amazing mascara, my girlfriend wanted one that was more thick than the cheap stuff. Thank you!
  • I always use this brand, but found out Anazon is not the place to buy.More expensive!
  • I've purchased this before from Sephora, and it was much better quality . The brush is awesome.But this time it was a if it was really old.So I don't know how it happened,but I won't purchase it from Amazon again.
View on Amazon


  • Boasts an "ergo-conic" brush that allows for ultra-precise, intuitive application
  • Contains soft fibers to lift each lash individually
  • Defines and coats lashes for spectacular volume and length
View on Amazon